I speak to a lot of different people about a range of ‘dieting’ ideas. Some of the stuff is good, however there are quite a few different practices that really make no sense at all. Below I have outlined my current top three of the later. If you do any of these then you need to stop. Stop yesterday!
- No eating after 7pm. There are some variations on this one: 6pm, 8pm, 9pm, 10pm… You get the idea.
The concept that needs to be understood is that excess calories any time of the day may help you to gain weight. It is just as sensible to say don’t eat between 10am and 3pm, or to not eat between 2pm and 7pm as it is to not eat after a certain time. Come to think of it, that is a good business idea… The ‘No eating between 9am and 11.30am diet’… Kind of has a ring to it no?
- Any diet based on eating a hell of a lot of one food. Examples include: Grapefruit, Chicken Soup, Lemonade… Usually based around a concept of ‘cleansing’ the body with a magical food.
This one really should not need too much of an explanation. What they don’t tell you is the other things they advise you to do (like eat fruits and vegetables, stop smoking, do a bit of exercise, and limit alcohol) are primarily responsible for any ‘cleansing’ (whatever that actually means) that goes on. Kind of like the stone soup story I remember as a child:
“The original stone was only a pretext to start the villagers sharing in a way that they would not have considered without the catalyst of the “stone soup” that they thought they were improving.”
Interestingly, this dieting ‘pretext’ works for many, many people. The thing about it that is questionable is the sustainability of it.
- Avoiding certain foods completely
I could not imagine my life without chocolate. Yet if an uneducated nutritionist looked at my diet, chocolate may well be something they would recommend for me to eliminate. Interesting thing about nutritional avoidance is that it more often ends in a binge.
Good news is the best (sustainable) ideas helping you get to and maintain a healthy weight involve avoiding crap foods that you know are bad from you and a bit of forward planning. No gimics. No fad. Something you can keep up for the rest of your life.